PDA

View Full Version : Akshardham is first culprit in Yamuna bed violation: Ramesh



Mrudul Godbole
07-01-2011, 09:38 PM
Akshardham is first culprit in Yamuna bed violation: Ramesh

The Akshardham Temple, built on banks of Yamuna River here, lacks environmental clearance, Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh said on Friday but conceded that nothing could be done about it now.

"Akshardham didn't get the clearance. Akshardham didn't apply for the environmental clearance," Ramesh told reporters here about the grand temple of Swaminarayan sect spread over 30-acre plot of land.

Asked whether Akshardham Temple was constructed by violating the environmental norms, he said, "It has already happened. What is yet to happen, we can stop that."

Pressed further, he said, "We can't demolish the Akshardham Complex. We have to protect the remaining river bed."

The temple, which was built over five years before being inaugurated on November 6, 2005, had courted controversies earlier also over environmental concerns.

Noting that he was seriously considering the concept of the River Regulation Zone notification, Ramesh said, "The manner in which the Yamuna river belt has been devastated by construction should be a wake up call to all of us."

"River belts...whether it is Akshardham Temple, which was the first culprit, then we had a series of other constructions. River belts have to be protected," he said.

Ramesh was also asked whether the Commonwealth Games village, built adjacent to Akshardham, also lacked green nod.

"Yes, it got the clearance. There was a village... I don't want to get into past, the clearance was given," he said.

Ramesh said the environmental clearance given to the Commonwealth Games village was upheld by the Supreme Court.

Emphasising the need of a River Regulation Zone (RRZ) notification to protect the rapidly vanishing river beds, the Minister said, "We are working on this concept and I hope within a next few months, we will be able to have an RRZ notification."

"Civil society organisations have given me the idea of RRZ like Coastal Regulation Zone notification," Ramesh added.

Link - http://www.indianexpress.com/news/akshardham-is-first-culprit-in-yamuna-bed-violation-ramesh/734643/

Sabyasachi Patra
07-01-2011, 10:57 PM
Religion has become the bane of our wilderness areas and wildlife. Violations of the environmental norms in the name of religion has to be stopped, be it a religion practiced by the majority or minority. In this case, the environment minister appears to have expressed his helplessness in tackling this situation.

Unfortunately, in this country, an ugly precedence has been set. Projects violating environment norms are still allowed to continue on the pretext that a significant amount of money has been spent in the project. From that perspective the Akshardham temple will get a reprive. The second reason is that this is a case of a religious project. And the third and probably an important reason is that the Akshardham temple is controlled by a very rich religious group or sect.

Last year, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has given a judgement that no religious places can come up in public land. For more on this read here: http://www.indiawilds.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2026
Unfortunately, the damage has already been done. The flood plains of the Yamuna has been lost forever. And to make matters worse the Common Wealth Games village was constructed on the flood plains. Yamuna - supposed to be a Goddess - according to hindu religion is violated upon by her own followers by taking her flood plains for the temple. And on the other hand, sports or development has taken its toll. There seems to be no respite for this Goddess. Or shall we say Goddess in Distress?

Sabyasachi